meghalaya schools
For representation only Credit: Representational image

For years, a child entering a government or aided school in Meghalaya could count on one thing: the State would hand them the books. That certainty has now been withdrawn. Under a sanction order issued on September 28, 2026 by the Samagra Shiksha Urban Resource Centre in East Khasi Hills, the Textbook Grant will be paid “only through DBT mode”.

Parents will receive Rs 250 per child in Classes I to V and Rs 400 in Classes VI to VIII, and are expected to find and buy the prescribed books themselves.

This is not one district’s experiment. Days earlier, the Meghalaya Chief Minister released the textbook grant, along with other Samagra Shiksha entitlements, through transfers to Aadhaar-linked accounts. The Project Approval Board has approved textbook funds for 5,19,816 children this year. Every one of them is affected.

No public explanation has accompanied this decision. No discussion paper, no visible consultation with parents or School Management Committees, and no published assessment have accompanied it. That silence is itself the first problem.

Consider the calendar, and the questions it raises. The order sanctions the grant for “the year 2026-27”, a financial year running from April 2026 to March 2027.

Meghalaya’s school year runs from February to December; the current session began on February 9, 2026. The order never says which school year the money is for.

If, as its timing suggests, it is meant for the 2027 session, families will receive cash about four months before any book is needed, and before DERT has even notified which books to buy.

That money will then sit in household accounts through Christmas and the winter months. Meanwhile, the order asks teachers to verify, within 45 to 60 days of the transfer, that the books have been bought.

That window falls in November and December, as the session closes on 16 December and the winter vacation begins, and before next year’s books are likely to reach the shops.

Teachers are being asked to confirm purchases that cannot sensibly have been made. Add to that the toil of rural travel to retailer shops, bringing on additional costs for already financially disadvantaged families, which in itself is against the principle of Right to Education and Samagra Shiksha.

There is a further mismatch. The order pays children who are currently enrolled. A child now in Class V would receive Rs 250, though next year she will need Class VI books, funded at Rs 400.

A child now in Class VIII would receive Rs 400 for elementary books he will no longer need once he moves to Class IX. A child joining Class I in 2027, not yet enrolled, would receive nothing.

Unless the Department has drawn up its lists in some other way, and the order does not say that it has, the money and the children will not match.

The order’s own terms do not hold together. One clause says parents “may utilise the sanctioned amount according to the actual requirement”; two clauses later, the money is declared not to be an unrestricted cash benefit. Books must be bought from a list that DERT has yet to notify. Proof of purchase is a parent’s self-declaration and a receipt kept “wherever available”.

No individual may receive more than two transfers. That leaves the third child of a family with no clear entitlement at all, in a state whose rural fertility rate stood at 3.3 in NFHS-5. Most tellingly, the order is silent on what happens to a child whose parent never buys the books.

Under direct supply, the State carried that risk. Under this order, the child carries it. And all of a sudden, this policy seems like passing the buck and washing hands of accountability.

We need not guess how this ends. Bihar introduced DBT for textbooks under Samagra Shiksha in 2017. A survey by its own government in 2018 found that only 18 per cent of children had managed to buy textbooks with the money.

Parents reported years without a rupee despite submitting bank and Aadhaar details; banks deducted minimum-balance charges; children without accounts simply fell out. Bihar abandoned textbook DBT in October 2022 and went back to handing books to children.

The economist Jean Drèze, who guided a field study there, put the problem plainly: cash for textbooks forces poor families to choose between books and food.

Uniform transfers have stumbled the same way in Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh.

Tamil Nadu withdrew a transport transfer for remote students because tribal families lacked bank accounts. That last lesson should weigh heavily in a tribal, hill state like Meghalaya.

Meghalaya is less prepared than any of these states. Its Aadhaar coverage stood at 84 per cent in June 2026, against nearly 98 per cent in Mizoram. In April 2025, coverage in West Khasi Hills and South Garo Hills was below 70 per cent.

The State itself told the Project Approval Board this year that its school enrolment figures fell largely because of Aadhaar-based data cleansing.

The Department already knows how transfers fail. When post-matric scholarships were paid this August, it had to advise unpaid students to link Aadhaar to their accounts and wait for the next cycle. College students can do that.

A mother in a remote village with three young children, a bank outlet hours away on a hill road, and a day’s wages at stake cannot be expected to do the same.

The stakes could not be higher. Meghalaya was the only state in the lowest grade of the Centre’s Performance Grading Index for 2023-24, and its PARAKH 2024 results were below the national average on every indicator. More than half of rural children aged 6 to 14 now attend private schools, according to ASER 2024.

Those who remain in government and aided schools come overwhelmingly from families for whom Rs 250 in cash competes with food and fuel. For them, a missing textbook can mean a lost year.

The law is on their side. Section 3(2) of the Right to Education Act bars any charge or expense that may prevent a child from completing elementary education. A book is the entitlement; a transfer that may arrive late, fall short or never arrive is a gamble on it.

The Centre does encourage DBT under Samagra Shiksha, and there is a fair case for it where families can choose among many sellers, as with uniforms. Prescribed textbooks are the opposite: fixed titles from a handful of publishers.

Nor does the scheme compel the change. This year’s PAB minutes for Meghalaya approve “Free Textbooks” with one stated condition: that books be distributed in time. The State has chosen this path, and the State must defend it. Do not change the policy all of a sudden.

That brings us to accountability. Shri Vijay Kumar Mantri, IAS, Commissioner and Secretary of Education since June 2024, should answer six questions in public.

Who took this decision, when, and after consulting whom?

Is the grant meant for the 2026 session or the 2027 session, and how will each child be matched to the class she will actually be in?

Does Rs 250 or Rs 400 buy a full set of prescribed books in every district?

How many parents have working, Aadhaar-seeded accounts, and how many transfers have already failed?

What will the Department do for the child who is left without books?

Has the Department factored in the costs of logistics for the parents, which might eat away at the DBT?

The textbook transfer is not an isolated episode. It follows a run of major decisions under the present leadership that were announced first and defended afterwards.

A notification of August 12 2026 bringing State Pay Scale vacancies under the Structured Pay Framework was withdrawn on September 17 after teachers’ bodies and the opposition objected.

Teachers’ associations walked out of a May 2026 meeting on the new Centralised Provident Fund Scheme that he chaired, alleging forced registration and the exclusion of key associations; the scheme now awaits the High Court.

The pattern runs further back. The Meghalaya Education Grant proposal provoked protests across all three regions in 2025.

The CM IMPACT guidebooks, developed by the Department, lifted SSLC pass rates from 55.80 to 87.10 per cent, but drew criticism for encouraging rote learning, for errors, and for the political branding of a public programme.

Despite the rampant uncertainties and hiccups, in a state that is already facing challenges in education, the endless defence never stops.

The need of the hour now is a structured performance review placed before the Legislative Assembly or the Parliament of India. It should ask how many major notifications since June 2024 were withdrawn or modified after objections, and whether each was preceded by consultation or an impact assessment.

It should test whether headline gains in pass rates and rankings are matched by independent measures such as PARAKH and ASER.

And it should establish whether entitlements, from textbooks to teachers’ dearness allowance, reached people on time. Education in Meghalaya is too important to be run on announcements and on the whims and fancies of the egos of people.

The immediate remedy is simple. Suspend the textbook transfer and start supplying books directly to every child before the 2027 session opens in February. Drop the two-child cap. Then publish the reasoning behind the decision, so that the public can judge it before parents start hitting the streets due to unresponsiveness.

A textbook is the cheapest and surest thing the State gives a child. Meghalaya gave its children books for years. It should explain why it stopped, and it should start again.

The author is a legal consultant based out of Bengaluru. Views expressed are that of the author and do not reflect EastMojo’s stance on this or any other matter.

Also Read: Beyond NEP: What will it take to make Assam’s four-year degree work?

Independent Journalism Needs You
Patrick Kurbah
Patrick Kurbah Reporter, EastMojo

You just read a story that took days to report. Help us keep our reporters on the ground in the Northeast.

For Rs 83/month - less than a cup of coffee
Ad-free reading, support and keep important stories alive
Become a Member
OR

Support once (any amount)

₹
(incl. 18% GST)
or
UPI QR Code
Scan to pay via UPI

Leave a comment