Border checkpoint controversy: How politics & security ‘clashed’ in Mizoram

How is the law and order situation in Mizoram? The answer depends on how you look at the numbers: while the state is generally considered peaceful, it is also infamous as a hub for drug smuggling and illegal trade. Stringent security checks are routine, especially in districts bordering Myanmar.

However, a recent incident has raised serious questions about the extent of these checks, and whether state politicians are being unjustly targeted by central forces.

The incident escalated on Thursday when Mizoram’s Power Minister, F. Rodingliana, found himself at the centre of an unusual confrontation with Assam Rifles personnel. While returning from Champhai, where he had been inspecting development projects, his convoy was allegedly halted at various checkpoints, sparking tensions that have since escalated into a state-wide debate.

The stops that sparked the debate

Minister Rodingliana’s journey was interrupted multiple times—first near Kawlbem, a remote village along the Myanmar border, and again at checkpoints near Ngopa and Seling. According to reports, Assam Rifles troops blocked the minister’s convoy with barricades and even laid spike strips across the road. 

Despite these actions, local reports said no formal checks were conducted on the minister’s vehicle, nor were any other vehicles on the road subject to inspection. This alleged selective approach led political observers and citizens to question whether the Assam Rifles were intentionally targeting the minister.

What’s behind the stops? Security or Intimidation?

Assam Rifles defended their actions, stating that their stops were part of efforts to prevent arms smuggling from neighbouring Manipur and Myanmar. However, their alleged focus on the minister’s convoy, while allowing other vehicles to pass unimpeded, has cast doubt on this claim.

Local sources suggested the stops were not about security at all, rather, they were an intentional disruption of the minister’s official duties. The Assam Rifles defended their stance in a rebuttal saying these reports are misleading and damage their reputation. 

The rebuttal published on Saturday said the media reports about the incident are misleading, malicious, and aimed at damaging their reputation. They stated that the convoy was not forcibly stopped, as alleged, but voluntarily halted at a Mobile Vehicle Check Post (MVCP) near Zokhawsang, where routine checks were being conducted. Assam Rifles clarified that the Minister’s vehicle was allowed to pass, but the convoy chose to stop, which contradicts claims that they were blocked.

The statement also accused the Minister’s staff, particularly his Personal Secretary, of engaging in provocative behaviour. They alleged that the Secretary exited his vehicle, verbally abused Assam Rifles personnel, removed his jacket, and forcibly took body cameras from the soldiers.

Other members of the convoy reportedly made disruptive and unpatriotic remarks, such as “go back to India.” Assam Rifles noted that shortly after the incident, a power outage occurred across their posts in Mizoram, which they believe was a deliberate move to obstruct their operations.

Assam Rifles also addressed an earlier incident on October 12 at Kwalbem, where it was claimed that an intoxicated jawan stopped and questioned the Minister. They denied these allegations, stating that the jawan has an exemplary 20-year service record and does not consume alcohol for religious reasons.

They explained that during the October 12th incident, the Minister’s convoy stopped after several vehicles had passed through a checkpoint, and the Minister confronted the soldiers, demanding that they dismantle the checkpoint. When informed that the soldiers were performing their duties, the Minister allegedly instructed his escort to forcibly take the jawan into their vehicle, transporting him to a nearby village.

The jawan was only released after the local Commander intervened. Assam Rifles described this as an obstruction of a soldier performing his duties and an attempt to tarnish the reputation of a dedicated serviceman.

The statement further rejected allegations questioning Assam Rifles’ operations in Mizoram due to the absence of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act (AFSPA). They emphasized that Assam Rifles is mandated to guard the 510 km Indo-Myanmar border and to counter the illegal drug trade under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act. They cited over 130 operations this year alone, leading to the seizure of narcotics worth ₹690 crore. 

Also on Saturday, the Power Minister gave his side of the explanation on how the situation escalated during an interaction with media persons. He alleged that after his pilot vehicle had passed through, his car was stopped, and the security personnel asked his name three times before allowing him to proceed only after noticing the nameplate and the Indian flag on his car.

He added that he believed the security personnel might have been intoxicated. The Minister further stated that he discussed the incident with the Assam Rifles commander in Kawlbem, who apologised to the minister, but an invitation to the commander in Ngopa to discuss resolutions was declined.

He also claimed that on October 13, Assam Rifles personnel attempted to stop him near Ngopa, but he managed to pass through. On October 17, three personnel allegedly stood in front of his car, prompting him to question whether they had any respect for the minister’s designation plate. It was on October 17 that the situation escalated. 

Mizoram Reacts: A question of authority

The incident has sparked a debate in Mizoram, with many seeing the repeated stopping of the minister’s convoy as an affront not just to the state government, but to the people of Mizoram. Social media has been flooded with reactions from citizens who feel that the central forces overstepped their boundaries, with some pointing out that Mizoram is not a disturbed area under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) and should not be treated as one.

Assam Rifles confirmed with EastMojo that the power supply to their various Company Operating Bases (COBs) was cut on the orders of the Mizoram Power Minister at 1400 hours. In certain areas, the power was out for four hours, while in others, the outage lasted up to seven hours. The power was eventually restored after the intervention of the Chief Minister.

Prominent journalist Vanneihthanga criticised the actions on Instagram, saying, “Stopping the Power Minister without proper reason multiple times, including outside Aizawl, should not be taken lightly. It is surprising to see Assam Rifles treating our leaders as if Mizoram is a troubled area.”

However, the minister’s alleged retaliation by cutting power to Assam Rifles bases has also drawn criticism. A local journalist, speaking on the condition of anonymity, stated, “The minister cutting power to Assam Rifles camps as a show of power is disgraceful. The right response would have been to inform the Mizoram Home Department and call for an inquiry, possibly even taking the matter to the Ministry of Home Affairs.”

While the state government has yet to make a statement, opposition parties have issued strong reactions to the incident. The Congress party’s lone MLA, C. Ngunlianchunga, also addressed the issue during a speech in Lawngtlai’s AOC locality. He stated, “The Assam Rifles harassing the Mizoram Power Minister while he was travelling is unacceptable. Mizoram is a peaceful state, not a disturbed area. For the Assam Rifles to trouble a minister is an insult to the people of Mizoram, and this should not be allowed to fade into silence.” 

The Mizo National Front (MNF) Legislature Party issued a statement on Friday morning, strongly condemning the actions of the Assam Rifles. The MNF said it considered the incident a disrespect of the Mizo people and their democratic state. ” We expect the Mizoram state government to uphold the integrity and democracy of the state and fulfil its responsibilities,” the statement read, emphasizing that the situation called for firm action from the state government.

The BJP President Vanlalhmuaka and BJP Legislature Party Leader Dr K. Beichhua sent a letter to Union Home Minister Amit Shah, condemning the alleged actions of the Assam Rifles towards the Mizoram Power Minister, urging the Home Minister to take necessary action if required. 

However, the state government has remained quiet. 

On Monday, Lalchhandama Ralte, Leader of the Opposition and MNF Vice President, criticised the state government, pointing out that both Congress and BJP spoke about the issue. He emphasised that in a democracy, elected officials hold the most power, and questioned why the Chief Minister and Home Minister have remained silent despite one of the 12 ministers facing such trouble. Ralte speculated whether this silence was due to fear of someone.

The apex student body of Mizoram, Mizo Zirlai Pawl (MZP), also condemned the incident, calling it a disrespect to the state’s democratic leadership. They demanded an investigation into the matter and urged that those responsible be transferred out of Mizoram before tensions escalate further.

MZP emphasised the need for peaceful coexistence between the people of Mizoram and the paramilitary and central forces stationed along the Indo-Myanmar border. They also raised concerns, questioning whether the complications arose due to the Assam Rifles’ reluctance to relocate to Zokhawsang. The relocation of Assam Rifles from the heart of Aizawl to Zokhawsang has been a long-debated issue, with promises made but not fulfilled by the previous MNF government, and assurances delayed by the current ZPM government.

Also Read: A majestic sight: Thirty-six snow leopards now call Arunachal home