The Manipur crisis is gradually exposing the soft underbelly of politics that prevails mainly among small northeastern states. Some northeastern states are too small and politically unviable to put up a fight against the Centre. They depend on the Centre for everything—from funds to schemes. Unable to make their case through democratic processes within the state government, the tribes and ethnic people of the small northeastern states resort to militancy to make their voices heard.
The propensity for militancy is mainly on account of the geography at the international border, poverty, backwardness, and the martial attributes of the people. Especially during elections and the award of government contracts, the MLAs have a symbiotic relationship with militant organisations where both parties benefit from the arrangement. Similarly, MLAs also share a symbiotic relationship with the state government, as without its favour, they are deprived of government benefits and projects, making them kowtow to the policies of the state government.
In September 2024, some members of a group called the “Imphal Naga Forum” had asked the state government to hold elections to the District Councils. The Imphal Naga Forum clarified that it was done by some vested persons and not by the group. Whatever the reasons, the suspicion at that point in time that some vested interest groups were collaborating with the establishment to create division within the tribal people is fully exposed now with the recent capitulation of the Hill Areas Committee (HAC) to the objective of the state government to put in place 18 handpicked political persons arbitrarily and two official nominees to constitute autonomous district councils (ADCs) in all the six district councils in Manipur before ADC elections are held.
The 18 handpicked persons will hold office until the election is held to constitute elected ADCs, and elections will obviously be held under the antiquated Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971. The recommendation of the HAC is to hold elections as soon as possible, but no one knows when ADC elections will actually be held, given the uncertainty and abnormal law and order situation, affording the arbitrarily nominated persons a free hand to manipulate the situation to their advantage.
The HAC meeting was held on 14th October 2024 in Imphal, which was obviously attended only by Naga MLAs. No MLAs from the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes would have attended the HAC meeting in Imphal. The quorum of the HAC, in the absence of 10 MLAs from the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes and its sanctity, is questionable.
Fully aware that the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes, who have been banished from the Imphal valley, are asking for separate administration, the actions of the Naga MLAs recommending holding elections under the antiquated Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, is shameful and amounts to a betrayal of tribal solidarity.
The Naga MLAs, who had attended the HAC meeting, should have declined and regretted the government’s reference dated 13.06.2024 of the Cabinet decision by stating that the political climate in Manipur, on account of the unresolved and ongoing ethnic conflict demonstrated by the fact that 10 MLAs from the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes have not attended the HAC meeting or any assembly sessions since the conflict erupted on 3rd May 2023, is not conducive to holding elections to the ADCs.
By toeing the state government line, the Naga MLAs have exposed their subservient nature to political leadership and the divide-and-rule policy of the dominant community. They should have stood tall by taking the high moral ground that this is not the right time to hold elections, as the ethnic conflict is unresolved. In fact, two ministers from the Kuki tribe have not been discharging their duties from Imphal.
The 10 Kuki-Zomi-Hmar MLAs have not attended any of the Assembly sessions after the ethnic flare-up on 3rd May 2023. There is not a single Kuki-Zomi-Hmar individual living in Imphal valley now. The Naga MLAs seem to have lost all moral fibre by recommending holding ADC elections under the abnormal situation, sans the participation of a community in the political, administrative, and legislative spheres in Imphal.
The entire matter smacks of the political high-handedness of the state government, unmindful of the misery of internally displaced persons (IDPs) with scant regard to the ongoing conflict. The governments at the Centre and state are to be blamed for their inability to bring back normalcy in the state even after 17 months of conflict.
Instead of working hard for a political solution to bring back normalcy, strident attempts are being made to browbeat an entire community, which constitutes 16% of the state’s population, by ignoring their sentiments.
Apart from these, the recommendation made by the HAC to nominate 18 persons and 2 officials to constitute each ADC until the time elected ADCs are in position is grossly unconstitutional, unlawful, arbitrary, and lacks fair play, transparency, and accountability. It is not known under what provision of law or the constitution such an appointment by nomination of the entire ADC is suggested.
Hill Areas CSOs should challenge the state government’s decision to nominate 20 persons for each ADC until elections are held in a court of law. Further, CSOs should preempt holding elections under the archaic Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, by the state government in connivance with pliable MLAs by demanding that elections for territorial councils only be held under Article 244, 244-A, and the Sixth Schedule.
However, if for valid reasons elections to ADCs cannot be held after the term of a duly elected ADC ends, the state government can always resort to promulgating an ordinance or the enactment of an Act for the amendment of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, enabling the appointment of an officer or authority after the expiry of the term of the ADC to perform all powers and duties of the council until such time normalcy returns for conducting fair and just elections.
After all, the archaic Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, is legislation of the state, and the state government can amend and modify the said Act as it wishes.
As already suspected, the demand of the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes for separate administration/UT/state will boil down to a territorial council type of local self-government.
The Sangai Express reported on 18th October 2024 that a territorial council for the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes could be in the offing. Under such circumstances, the recommendation of the HAC meeting of 14th October 2024, attended by Naga MLAs, has exposed their weakness and shameful action before the general public.
The news about a territorial council for the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes, however, raises the question of what will happen to the ADCs of the hill districts predominantly inhabited by Nagas.
Will they be left out of the dispensation likely to be granted to the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes? The likelihood of being left out is very high, as no demand has been made recently by the Naga CSOs of Manipur or by the Naga peace negotiators. Manipur Nagas are faced with a dilemma: whether to keep mum and continue with the antiquated Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, and eat humble pie, or raise their voice now and ask for similar dispensation.
In my humble opinion, there is no conflict or contradiction with the Naga peace talks, which are expected to bring about a settlement of greater nature if the hill districts predominantly inhabited by Nagas also ask for a territorial council similar to that of the Kuki-Zomi-Hmar tribes. Making the demand now by Naga CSOs will help hasten the conclusion of a political settlement to bring peace in Manipur.
Also Read:
