Samarendra Nath Pandey was born on October 26, 1927. He was a prolific writer of Bengali pulp fiction under the pen name Swapan Kumar. He wrote hundreds of pulp fiction detective books and created the iconic detective character, Dipak Chatterjee. According to his publishers, all his books sold like hotcakes back in the day.
Sadly, Swapan Kumar and his art were never recognized as anything more than a means of instant gratification. His books are no longer remembered as part of Bengali literature gems, nor are his characters and stories fondly handed down from generation to generation. On the contrary, his work is considered crass, bizarre, and often devoid of literary value or merit.
While other detectives like Feluda and Byomkesh have found a strong footing in popular Bengali culture and Artscape, Dipak Chatterjee has been reduced to a laughing stock and forced to languish in some dilapidating library among his last surviving collection of quickly disappearing Swapan Kumar pulp novellas.

Debaloy Bhattacharya’s highly experimental film, “Shri Swapankumarer Badami Hyenar Kobole,” attempts to show us what would transpire if Dipak, like Byomkesh and Feluda, existed in this world at a time when Byomkesh and Feluda existed and were ever so popular, and what would happen if Dipak Chatterjee was called back to action in a fresh swashbuckling Swapan Kumar story involving a new world-threatening danger coming from an entity referred to as the Badami Hyena.
Through his unique narrative style, Debaloy Bhattacharya makes Swapan Kumar and his fictional detective extensively interact as the story gets written in real-time with the real-life manifestation of it revealed to us in an experimental form of exposition.
Rediscovering Dipak Chatterjee and Underlining a Society’s Hypocrisy Towards Its Own:
In the very first scene of the film, Dipak Chatterjee (played by Abir Chatterjee) is called back into action, entrusted to retrieve a McGuffin, as is customary in most stories of this nature. Dipak Chatterjee has been forgotten and left to rot by Bengali society, which prefers better-written, nuanced, Tagore-quoting, and intelligent detectives over gun-toting sleuths who can fire 30 shots from two pistols with 12 bullets each without reloading. Debaloy Bhattacharya instantly takes us into the mindscape of Dipak Chatterjee, and through his interactions with the author Swapan Kumar (played by Paran Banerjee), explains how badly Bengali society has treated them by enjoying the pleasure they provided through their stories but never recognizing their contribution and art.

This portion of the film goes on to define the ever-present desire of writers and artists to enjoy love, praise, and accolades and is by far the most heart-warming portion. This part essentially criticizes the hypocrisy of Bengali society, which is willing to take pleasure from a creation but will shun it for being too low to feature in their living room alongside other more recognized and established works of literature.
This portion also underscores the inadequacies in the story writing, the inherent errors, the logical fallacies, and the over-the-top nature of the stories that Swapan Kumar wrote. The director then, through his protagonist, questions the author whether he can adapt to the current sensibilities and incorporate elements into his story that are more in line with what resonates with audiences these days.
Swapan Kumar obliges and adds elements to his trademark formula that not only bring back memories of some of the more stellar presentations of detective stories in Bengali cinema but also keep intact the over-the-top nature of Swapan Kumar’s literature. This shows that pulp fiction when presented with flair, can find its footing among even the most dismissive of audiences.
Reshaping Pulp Fiction in The Current Context:
Many point to the fact that this film lacks a cohesive narrative and is more about individual set pieces and the novelty of resurrecting a forgotten hero who once entertained generations. However, I beg to differ. The film’s opening credits roll at a juncture when Dipak Chatterjee comes back for one last time to save his assistant, Ratanlal, and just before that, he challenges his author to write a story where the detective solves the crime with his brains and includes references to Rabindranath Tagore and his songs.
This is exactly what transpires throughout the rest of the film. Swapan Kumar zealously writes a story that is complicated and has more characters, plot twists, and antagonists than ever before. I watched closely as the author even introduced an antagonist from his previous popular story and wove him into the narrative here, signalling his intention to take on the characteristics of the Byomkesh and Feluda stories, where some of the major antagonists like Maganlal Meghraj (Feluda) and Anukul Babu (Byomkesh) make reappearances in different stories.
Swapan Kumar also ensures that “Badami Hyenar Kobole” is an extensive and nuanced story where each character has its own motivations, and all of them undergo different arcs throughout the story. The identity of the Badami Hyena is not revealed until the very end of the film.
All these qualities in the film ensure that the story is unlike anything we have seen in pulp fiction but also retains elements that we enjoy about pulp fiction, such as over-the-top action, background score, grand entries, and a plethora of colourful albeit questionable characters and their actions.
The Comedy Plays a Subtle Yet Effective Role:
Comedy plays an important role in both the story and the film. While it may not be the laugh-out-loud kind of comedy one might expect from films of this nature, it is executed with enough panache and attention to extracting genuine emotions to ensure that the humour resonates.
The majority of the comedy stems from the interactions between Swapan Kumar and Dipak Chatterjee. Dipak Chatterjee’s critique of Swapan Kumar’s cheap tropes, over-the-top presentation, and sometimes logical and factual errors brings out a lot of humour. While there are moments when you empathize with the author and understand how difficult it must have been for him to make a living writing these books alone, you cannot help but chuckle at some of the moments where Dipak points out that Swapan Kumar’s mistakes have made him a laughing stock in front of the entire world and his readers.
This banter becomes more intense as the story progresses. There are moments in the film where Swapan Kumar writes a certain dialogue for Dipak to deliver, and he refuses to speak the lines in real time. I found this approach to comedy disarming. Additionally, other more conventional comedic moments also worked for me.
The Powerful Performances Form the Emotional Core of The Film:
This film heavily relies on performances. One cannot imagine pulling off its execution style unless the performances were spot on. It’s one of the most challenging tasks for a star like Abir Chatterjee to make fun of himself or his character, especially with a straight face. Yet, that’s exactly what we get from him in this film.
I cannot praise enough how well he depicts the frustration, anger, hurt, and embarrassment of the character of Dipak Chatterjee through his portrayal. As the arc of the character unfolds and we see him as the iconic detective envisioned by Swapan Kumar, we witness a stark change in how Abir approaches these parts of the character.
His ability to efficiently shift gears to keep up with the different nuances of the character and the expansive nature of the storytelling, with its numerous twists, is wonderful.
The subtle romantic portions of the film that Abir shares with Shruti Das were heart-warming with Shruti doing an equally good job with her character of Tashi. Both actors created an interesting and effective chemistry that resonated with the audience.
At 83 years old, Paran Banerjee still possesses the enthusiasm and magic of a 15-year-old. He brings the same excitement, simplicity, and charm to his roles. These characteristics, coupled with his screen presence, make even some of the inane and inert characters magical. So, it’s no surprise that a well-written and quirky character like Swapan Kumar would not only suit him but also provide him with the perfect opportunity to captivate his audience with his performance.
He does exactly that here and it was easily the best aspect of the film for me.
Crafting The Perfect Atmosphere with Colour, Sound, And Structure:
The music in the film was one of its most noticeable aspects, as it always appeared at the right moment and elevated what was on display. This was achieved through both the background score and some beautiful songs. Two of my favourite tracks from the film were “Nirbashit Chand” and “Missile Utshobe.”
There was something magical about how these tracks were featured and the actions of the characters that complimented these songs. The other tracks were just as good if not better. This includes the Rabindranath Tagore creation, “Phoole Phoole,” which played during Dipak Chatterjee’s introductory action sequence.
The cinematography and editing of the film complemented its signature style. There is a lot of usage of colour to enhance the look and feel, something that will be best enjoyed when watching the film on the biggest screen possible. Unfortunately, it was never released in Assam, so my only option was my 32-inch television.
Watching it at night without any distractions and in complete darkness, I was able to appreciate the subtle uses of hues and colours and the impact that the cinematography was trying to create on my subconsciousness.
However, the editing of the film could have been crisper. My issue here isn’t so much about the transition between one portion of a scene to another, but more so on the transition between different scenes that felt very indulgent. Yes, no matter how wonderful the songs may be, they do tend to slow down the proceedings.
The innumerable interactions between Swapan Kumar and Dipak Chatterjee also lose their appeal towards the end of the film and become somewhat repetitive. The story is also a little too thin to be stretched to the extent that it is, with some unnecessary elements added in the end for shock value.
This might be just another way for the director to show the over-the-top nature of Swapan Kumar’s literature, but it didn’t necessarily work here.
Final Words:
“Shri Swapankumarer Badami Hyenar Kobole” is truly a unique film in its style, story, performance, and how the director wants you to perceive reality. While it wholeheartedly embraces its over-the-top nature and eccentricities, it never forgets to critique, ridicule, and then, in the end, underline the magic of what it is and why it was so engrossing for such a large chunk of readers in Bengal.
While stories like these and writers like Swapan Kumar would have had a cult following in any other place, the film tries to at least make him a name that the current generation remembers and appreciates for being a source of entertainment and escapism for the generations that came before theirs. This idea alone makes this film worth the price of admission. “Shri Swapankumarer Badami Hyenar Kobole” is a must-watch in every sense of the term.
Rating: 4/5 (4 out of 5 Stars)
